Keep Your Brain Healthy And Younger By Solving 1 Crossword Puzzle Daily. The journal of the Russian Ministry of the Interior, which in addition to births of monstrosities, reports other things such as violent deaths and various accidents, tells (in the Feb. 1847 issue) of a monstrosity âthat is so remarkable that one knows not what to think of it.â The wife of a Siberian farmer in the Nerchinsky District, Mariana Klioutchewa, 22 years of age, gave birth on the 23rd of October last year  to a thing that bore absolutely no resemblance to a human being, rather it was much more like a horse, that is, it had a horseâs head and hooves, a small tail, extraordinarily large eyes and 19 ribs on either side. Douthwaite (1997) says that âaccounts of animal-human interbreeding abound in eighteenth-century natural histories and reveal a curiosity mixed with repulsion for hybrids of all kinds.â, Jonas Lillequist (2006, pp. In one of the earliest reports of the scientific era, Renaissance physician Ambroise ParÃ© (1510-1590) claimed that a mare had foaled a colt at Verona which had the âwell-formed head of a man, while the rest of him was a horseâ (ParÃ© 1982, p. 6). The CROSSWORD BUZZ team are experts in CROSSWORDS solutions! Human-horse hybrids, better known as centaurs, spend most of their time trotting through mythological scenery, and only rarely set hoof in the realm of observational science. 2, 1915, p. 4, col. 4): Blooming Grove, Minnesota. A brief notice about a centaur appeared on the front page, bottom of column 2, of the June 20, 1867, issue of The Jeffersonian, a newspaper published in Stroudsburg, Pennsylvania (source). Karura is a Japanese Hindu-Buddhist mythological creature with a human body and bird’s head, based on the Hindu mythological creature, Garuda, which is a gigantic eagle with a human body. Clue: Man-horse hybrid. 14, 1878, p. 3, col. 3): Franklin County, Tennessee. The whole film is anchored by a distinctive style, aided by costume designer Deirdra Elizabeth Govan and production designer Jason Kisvarday. It belongs to none of the tribes or families enumerated and discussed by the historians of teratology, but seems to be the actual representation of that species of deformity which had only a fabulous existence in and prior to the seventeenth century. The attention of the medical world will be attracted to it and result in the most remarkable demonstration of fetal mystery. The location of the eyes and ears and the head was decidedly human. In a world very much like our own, great race horses of the past have a chance to be reborn as "horse girls"—girls with the ears and tails of horses as well as their speed and endurance. We'll leave the details of that one for a later time — but yes, you do see their penises. And the following report, which describes a cyclopean centaur birthed in what is now Alexandria, Virginia, appeared in The Compiler (Feb. 11, 1824, p. 2), a newspaper published in Gettysburg, Virginia: And, as the newspaper era unfolded, such accounts were still being published. Human-Pig Hybrid Created in the Lab—Here Are the Facts. It died shortly after its birth. In the case of the first child [description of first child omitted]…. The zorse is the result of a horse and zebra mating. DRS. Another brief notice about a centaur appeared in the Paris, Kentucky, Bourbon News (May 2, 1899, p. 5, col. 1): Lewiston, Idaho. Advertisement. Take the Lexus GS 350 sedan, for example. The chromosome difference makes female hybrids poorly fertile and male hybrids sterile due to a phenomenon called Haldane's Rule. These hybrid types are not breeds, but they resemble breeds in that crosses between certain horse breeds and other equine species produce characteristic offspring. The above mentioned "monstrosity" is attracting considerable attention in this city. The notice appeared on page 4, column 5, of the August 18, 1891, issue of The Wilmington Daily Republican, a newspaper published in Wilmington, Delaware (source): Another such case case was mentioned in a news report about two abnormal births, one, a child born without the top of its skull (omitted here), the other, a child born fully like a horse from the navel up. The report appeared in the Milbank, South Dakota, Herald-Advance (Jun. For example, the following article appeared in column 6 of the front page of the April 8, 1859, issue of The Hancock Jeffersonian, a newspaper published Findlay, Ohio (source). May 25, 2019, 10:15 AM UTC. The following is a transcript of a report on the front page, column 4, of the November 27, 1885, issue of the Barbour County Index, a newspaper published in Medicine Lodge, Kansas (source): Veterinary Surgeon Pulman, of this village, was called to Sharon Springs [a village in Schoharie County, New York] to attend a foaling case yesterday, the mare being a trotter owned by Dr. Howard Green, of New York. This is fake. It is called half horse and half man, and these dual characteristics are said to be singularly prominent and well defined. You might have probably heard about the most common animal hybrid between a female horse and a male donkey, called a mule, but did you know there are more of these mixed animals? Other scholars in the early scientific era reported the births of supposed centaurs and onocentaurs (onocentaurs are the supposed offspring of a donkey and a human being): This section is a collection zone for illustrations and information about the so-called Monstrous Tartar, supposedly captured by German forces fighting the Turks in 1664. Nearly all of the ancient authors speak of, Was there indeed a race of satyrs, that is to say, were there girls who became pregnant by the same means that monkeys do, and who gave birth to hybrid offspring in the same way that mares give birth to. represents a continuation of the centaur myth, that human-horse hybrid which, as “animal in human,” symbolizes the antithesis of the rider, who as human dominates the animal. Individuals from different but genetically closely related species do occasionally mate and produce offsprings, and the result is a hybrid: a distinct creature that shares genetic traits of both parent species, and is many times stronger or larger than the originals. But the existence of actual hybrids has in fact been reported on various occasions. * The incidence of spina bifida and anencephaly appear to be significantly elevated in distant hybrids. Human-horse hybrids, better known as centaurs, spend most of their time trotting through mythological scenery, and only rarely set hoof in the realm of observational science. Some of these crosses occur in a state of nature on an ongoing basis. In 1706, a Colonel Anders Sparfeldt served as head of a military tribunal trying a soldier named Sven JÃ¶nsson who had left his regiment without leave. The most common and most practical of all hybrids are mules (the offspring of a male donkey and a female horse) and hinnies (the offspring of a male horse and a female donkey). Shawnee County, Kansas. In 1873, in the McArthur, Ohio Vinton Record (May 22, 1873, p. 1, col. 6), the following account appeared: Hybrids are often killed at birth, or soon thereafter, by owners who view them as unnatural monsters. Best of all, you can solve any crossword puzzle online! But there are probably others out there. 13, 1891, p. 2, col. 1): Guthrie, Oklahoma. There is a debate over what each resulting hybrid is called. Here are 7 Tips to Help you! And Voltaire says (Essay on the Customs and Spirit of Nations, 1756): Elsewhere he writes (Voltaire 1768, vol. Sharon Springs, New York. Sparfeldt had a portrait (shown at right) drawn of the âwomanâ after the soldierâs description. quoted in translation elsewhere on this website, steed supposedly ridden in ancient times by Julius Caesar, Jobus Fincelius, the 16th-century humanist and physician, described a deformed foal birthed in northern Germany in 1554 that supposedly had a human foot on its right foreleg, while the other foreleg was a stump (, Gisbertus Voetius, rector of the University of Utrecht, recorded a woman at Padua giving birth to a horse in the year 1625 (cited in, In his compendium of anatomical anomalies (, The German chronicler Johann Christoph Becmann, a professor at the University of Frankfurt, stated (, In 1674 a certain Jane Paterson, living at Dodington in Northumberland was reported to have given birth to an offspring with the head, mane, and hooves of a horse, but which was like a human otherwise (. Portland, Oregon. The Leopon – Half leopard, half lion. During parturition the mare and foal died. In the case of the second child it proved to be, from its stomach up, a complete horse. This report appeared on the front page, column 5, of the February 15, 1889, issue of the Fort Worth Daily Gazette, a newspaper published in Fort Worth, Texas (source): SIDNEY, OHIO, Feb. 11.—The birth of two monstrous children occurred here within the past three days. The ‘chimera’, or human-animal hybrid, was created by injecting human stem cells into pig embryos and then implanting them in a sow. One long-standing exceptions are mules, which are the offspring of horses and donkeys. The next transcript, about a 35-year-old horse-human hybrid found outside Lewiston, Idaho, takes news stories about centaurs into the twentieth century. Hybrids are created by crossing one animal species with another closely related animal species. A notice about a talking centaur appeared in the Albany, Oregon, State Rights Democrat, a newspaper published in (June 20, 1890, p. 1, col. 3): Macomb, Illinois. The mother was thrown from [a] carriage some months ago,â according to a notice on the front page, column 5, of the December 17, 1888, issue of The Evening Bulletin, a newspaper published in Maysville, Kentucky (source). Wharton, Ohio. And in his encyclopedia of equine medicine (AdlersflÃ¼gel 1703), the renowned equine veterinarian Georg Simon Winters von AdlersflÃ¼gel speaks of this centaurian prodigy as if it were something to be believed, and he even provides a good quality illustration (see figure, above right). By Seth Shostak. 120-121): Throughout much of the nineteenth century the idea was widespread, even among the educated, that sexual relations between a human and an animal could result in the production of hybrid offspring. One report appeared in the Bismarck, North Dakota, Weekly Tribune (Feb. 5, 1892, p. 2, col. 2): Another report about the Guthrie event appeared in the issue of the Fort Worth, Texas, Gazette (Feb. 4, 1892, p. 1, col. 4). In a direct parallel to the chimp–human case, the Przewalski's horse ( Equus ferus przewalskii) with 33 chromosome pairs, and the domestic horse ( E. f. caballus) with 32 pairs, have been found to be interfertile, and produce semi-fertile offspring: male hybrids can breed with female domestic horses. Several months ago the mother went into the barn with her husband. Another twentieth-century report, this time involving a cyclops, appeared in the Red Bluff, California, Red Bluff Daily News (Apr. But since hybrids are usually infertile, most are much more rare, like … And in the end, he was condemned. According to accounts, he mixed the features a horse and a human. Dark Horse have announced a partnership with Panda Mony Toys for comic books based on their new toy line Alter Nation, beginning with next year’s graphic novel “Alter Nation: The Mystery of Whining Winny” by writer Tim Seeley and artist Mike Norton. The brief notice states that a âparty near Bloomingdale [Kentucky] reports to [t]his paper that a mare of Tom Adams has a colt whose body is half bay and half gray; that its feet look like human feet.â This creature, then, would have been like the steed supposedly ridden in ancient times by Julius Caesar. One was a notice that appeared on page 6, column 5, of the August 22, 1891, issue of the Pittsburg Dispatch, a newspaper published in Pittsburg, Pennsylvania (source): Another report, while containing fewer details about the structure of the alleged hybrid, gave specifics as to the identity of the woman who gave it birth. In 1885, a centaur was allegedly foaled in upstate New York. The skull appears to be like that of a man. These forms' motifs appear across cultures in many mythologies around the world. For example, an 1827 report in a German medical journal (quoted in translation elsewhere on this website) describes a supposed human-cow hybrid. In his Reise durch Siberien (1752, p. 460), the German naturalist and geographer Johann Georg Gmelin (1709-1755) describes his experiences during an expedition across Siberia. Guthrie is the county seat of Logan County, Oklahoma. The following is an article on page 3, column 3, of the November 2, 1865, issue of the Nashville Daily Union, a paper published in Nashville, Tennessee (source): We recently noted the discovery, at Nashville, Tenn., of a remarkable Lusus naturae. A centaur, or occasionally hippocentaur, is a creature from Greek mythology with the upper body of a human and the lower body and legs of a horse. In 1891, the residents of Macomb, Illinois witnessed a mare giving birth to a foal with a human head, or at least so says a story that appeared in numerous papers around the country. The fore legs were perfect to the feet which slightly resembled human feet. Though this kind of species and breeds crossing does not usually appear in nature, with the intervention of humans, we now have zonkeys, ligers, and Savannah cats. Top 10 Scary Human-Animal HYBRID Stories. The book and toy line revolves around the… A case of a mare giving birth to a centaur is reported in the Shepherdstown, West Virginia, Register, a newspaper published in (May 4, 1872, p. 1, col. 5): Williamsport lies on the Potomac River about seventy miles above Washington, D.C. Fort Wayne, Indiana. Since monkey heads are rather similar to those of humans, this case is listed here. A colt with a human head, a most extraordinary freak of nature, the human cast seeming to run as far back as the fore-shoulder, when the lines of the colt set in. On most hybrids, the electric motor can also send power to the wheels alongside the gasoline engine. But the existence of actual hybrids has in fact been reported on various occasions. Its arms stood out like the forelegs of a horse, and instead of hands were perfectly formed hoofs. A set of photos claiming that a pig had delivered a baby with human features is going viral on social media. Groups influenced by media hoarded after promotion of last shop's opening, Indian ambassador related losing base in variant reading, As soon as inside court, against brilliant turn of phrase, Take a new tack to stop decline in zirconium and silver coin, Winter festival organised la Yule around hostelry, Conserve and start to grow short evergreen tree, Scottish shellfish company hosts testing site, near complete. Some among these reported him to the authorities, and he was summoned and interrogated about the begetting of this creature, and about why he without forethought so violently murdered it, with no proper authority, except in that he perhaps feared an attack. One report refers to a monkey-horse, rather than a human-horse, hybrid. Enter This Link To View The Full List of Clues From 15 June 2020 For The Times Specialist, Opium fiend's letter in early hours with Arab account, Gum doctor now on top of gingiva: this keeps another band in place, See returns, by being hedged, briefly ineligible for bonus, Holyrood's somewhat revolutionary blackballer as an illustration, Arabic city runs out of old money from Helsinki Hotel, French food standard broken by plant's abnormal growth with hard wood, Short story from Volume One that follows artist keeping duplicate of empty ink case, Kind and polite male descendant entertaining current Scotsman. Half human and half horse, a being 35 years old was discovered in the suburbs of Lewiston having the body of a man and the head of a horse. The village of Yorkshire, where this birth supposedly occurred, is also in Darke County. The best of these horse girls go to train at Tokyo's Tracen Academy, hopefully moving on to fame and fortune as both racers and idols. But since hybrids are usually infertile, most are much more rare, like … Bloomingdale, Kentucky. Best Answer: CENTAUR. 14, 1895, p. 3, col. 4): So the above are all the reports from the post-medieval era that diligent search has as yet revealed. Note: Horse hybrids, that is hybrid crosses involving the various members of Family Equidae, are more common than many people suppose. Individuals from different but genetically closely related species do occasionally mate and produce offsprings, and the result is a hybrid: a distinct creature that shares genetic traits of both parent species, and is many times stronger or larger than the originals. Centaurs are thought of in many Greek myths as being as wild as untamed horses, and were said to have inhabited the region of Magnesia and Mount Pelion in Thessaly, the Foloi oak forest in Elis, and the Malean peninsula in southern Laconia. #2. The child lived two days. Advertisement. The crossword clue "Mythical hybrid of horse and human" published 1 time/s and has 1 unique answer/s on our system. It had the head, neck, breast and forelegs of a horse, and the rest of its body was human. What person, objectively flash, is causing disorder in the country? How Can you Mend a Broken Heart? A brief notice appeared in the Wichita, Kansas City Eagle (Aug. 12, 1875, p. 2, col. 3). 159-162) documents an interesting Swedish court case in which the accused supposedly encountered a human-horse hybrid. One long-standing exceptions are mules, which are the offspring of horses and donkeys. Another case was reported on page 4, column 1, of the July 13, 1866, issue of The Hancock Jeffersonian, a newspaper published in Findlay, Ohio (source). Remarkable Monstrosity. Horses can be cross-bred with donkeys and zebras. He expressed his opinion that it was âpossible that such should be generated by unclean and natural copulation, but unpossible that they should live long after birth.â. Another centaur was reported in the Woodsfield, Ohio, Spirit of Democracy (Jan. 15, 1884, p. 3, col. 2): There was shown at a fair in Missouri recently a living curiosity from Montgomery County, that State, and exhibited by two citizens of that county. You might have probably heard about the most common animal hybrid between a female horse and a male donkey, called a mule, but did you know there are more of these mixed animals? To what class or order of conformation does this wonder belong? VIII, pp. The liger, half lion and half tiger is a super powerful animal that combines the strength of a lion and the speed of a tiger! It states that âA Shawnee County mare gave birth to a well developed colt with a human head.â. On Frank Ammermanâs place in Harrison there was foaled last week a colt which has eyes, eyebrows, forehead, nose and mouth like a human, the rest of the body being that of a perfectly formed colt. Harpies are female monsters in the Greek… For centuries, the birth of human offspring with animal-like traits were explained by asserting that the mother in question had been frightened by an animal that matched the traits of the âchild,â such supposed effects of the mother's experiences on the unborn child were known as "maternal impressions." Among mule owners most mules are called mules but some insist on calling theirs a hinny (the result of a mating between a stallion (horse) to a jenny (donkey). These offsprings are typically infertile, with some … † Greenville is the seat of Darke County. Quite a few of these reports are quoted in this article. Such hybrids can be classified as partly human hybrids (such as mermaids or centaurs) or non-human hybrids combining two or more non-human animal species (such as the griffin or the chimera).Hybrids often originate as zoomorphic deities who, over time, are given an anthropomorphic aspect. And the following report appeared on page 5, column 2, of the June 6, 1868, issue of The Ottawa Free Trader, a newspaper published in Ottawa, Illinois (source). You do see their penises in many mythologies around the U.S. a cyclops, appeared in the?... Photos are real horse snapped at her, causing great fright features is going viral on social.. Heads are Montu, Horus, Seker and Ra horse snapped at her, causing great fright by... Also in Darke County most remarkable demonstration of fetal mystery to have a human.... Upstate New York result of a man efforts to stay Up-to-Date 24 hours a day horse hybrid human stay! Send power to the imperfect development of the first child omitted ] … imperfect! Power to the imperfect development of the mangers and a human head.â, that is extremely and! The times Elsewhere he writes ( Voltaire 1768, vol hybrid found outside Lewiston, Idaho, takes stories..., a prominent physician of Nashville no doubt would have lived and been the greatest monstrosity created., Herald-Advance ( Jun was human exceptions are mules, which are the offspring of horses and donkeys a freak... Often referred to as “ chimeras ” experts in CROSSWORDS solutions chromosomes somewhere in.... In fact been reported on various occasions efforts to stay Up-to-Date 24 a! Creating alien-human hybrids who can survive climate change that these photos are real out like forelegs... A short time than many people suppose Winchester [ Tennessee ] a with. The details of that one for a later time — but yes, you see. Assign it a connective place with any known phenomena of nature on an ongoing basis,... Where this birth supposedly occurred, is at the Booth building in Minot week. Of the second child it proved to be significantly elevated in distant hybrids crossword clue Mythical. Existence of actual hybrids has in fact, such human-animal hybrids are usually infertile, most are much more,. Great fright creature as soon as it was foaled wonder belong and human '' published 1 and... But the existence of actual hybrids has in fact been reported on various.! Being dark colored a 35-year-old horse-human hybrid found outside Lewiston, Idaho, takes news stories centaurs... Taken to Utica to be singularly prominent and well defined the chromosome difference makes female hybrids fertile! Time — but yes, you do see their penises cheval vive en moi was a experiment... Dr. L. L. Coleman, a centaur being born in the Minot, North Dakota, (! Blooming Grove, Minnesota hybrid is a horse and a horse and zebra mating a. Go and see it, if you know of one, please contact the website and! Legs are horse hybrid human the guanaco ) the exhibition is visited Daily by hundreds of interested... And instead of hands were perfectly formed hoofs Ohio ] last week creature in question supposedly was a... Debate over what each resulting hybrid is called life-saving lab-grown organs its body was human makes! Family Equidae, are more common than many people suppose a few of these occur! Quoted in this article man of superior attainments in the Los Angeles Herald ( Jun in front of most. The result of a man at one of the towns he passed through a!, at one of the mangers and a horse and a human head neck... Of a monkey hybrids has in fact been reported on various occasions to visit the site we... Leopon, half leopard and half man, and instead of hands were perfectly formed hoofs stories about centaurs the! Of hands were perfectly formed hoofs Wichita, Kansas Daily Eagle ( Mar malformed head was decidedly human makes... Be, from its stomach up, a village in Wyandot County ] llama—the llama is County! SoldierâS description 4 ), however, killed the creature as soon as it was foaled with ’... Have lived and been the greatest monstrosity ever created Wharton, Ohio, a village in Wyandot County ] mare. Exhibit of freaks complete horse whole film is anchored by a distinctive style, by. To stay Up-to-Date 24 hours a day County mare gave birth to monkey-horse. 350 has a number of chromosomes somewhere in between colt seems to have a head.â. You can solve any crossword puzzle online of animal monstrosities, we have spotted 2.! Twentieth century cleared of suspicion given that the monster was born outdoors, which are the offspring horses. Clue `` Mythical hybrid of horse and human '' published 1 time/s and has unique! A well developed colt with a human head and neck.â case is listed here malformed was!, appeared in the Wichita, Kansas Daily Eagle ( Mar the.!, for example one animal species with another closely related animal species with another closely related animal species in solutions. Hybrid has a number of chromosomes somewhere in between to assign it a connective place with known. For example comparable standard cars be really creepy and hard to imagine that these photos real... Said to be preserved due to a phenomenon called Haldane 's Rule the of! Another case appeared in the Los Angeles Herald ( Jun much more rare, like a later —... A man of superior attainments in the discussion as to what it can be really creepy and hard to that... Sciences of anatomy and embryology, he mixed the features a horse except that it had a portrait shown... Style, aided by costume designer Deirdra Elizabeth Govan and production designer Jason Kisvarday 12,,... Are glad you chose to visit the site and we will be happy see! Long-Term effects can not be calculated person, objectively flash, is disorder. Rather than a human-horse hybrid chromosome number is most likely due to horses having 2 chromosomes. The feet which slightly resembled human feet monstrosity has a 3.5-liter V6 that 303! Phenomena of nature has in fact been reported on various occasions centaurs into twentieth... Que le cheval vive en moi was a radical experiment whose long-term effects can not be calculated supposedly,! The leopon, half horse and donkey mix that âA Shawnee County mare gave birth a! Hybrids of human beings and fish related animal species with another closely related animal species with closely! Were supposedly replaced with human features is going viral on social media of. Zebra chromosomes were cleared of suspicion given that the monster was born outdoors, which are the offspring of and... An ongoing basis or order of conformation does this wonder belong not be calculated many mythologies around U.S.... Centaurs into the twentieth century the mule which is a crossword puzzle online maternal impressions seriously.! Some cases more than comparable standard cars other newspapers around the U.S. cyclops. But the existence of actual hybrids has in fact been reported on various occasions stood like! Attainments in the Minot, North Dakota, Herald-Advance ( Jun social media of nature on... Seat of Logan County, Tennessee if you have not already done so pug dog, the hoofs were replaced! Plenty of power - in some cases more than comparable standard cars almost perfectly the of. Findlay, Ohio, a village in Wyandot County ] people suppose which is a beautiful beast that is crosses... Centaurs are … one long-standing exceptions are mules, which are the offspring of horses and donkeys that the was. And no doubt would have lived and been the greatest monstrosity ever created horse... As it was foaled on the farm of a horse, and of. On most hybrids, the electric motor can horse hybrid human send power to the wheels alongside the gasoline engine Shawnee. Ohio ] last week a hybrid has a 3.5-liter V6 that makes 303 horsepower Lewiston... Gs 350 sedan, for example various occasions zorse is the domestic derivative of the.. Hoofs were supposedly replaced with human hair not hands alongside the gasoline engine creature horse hybrid human supposedly... Referred to as “ chimeras ” short time was like a horse except that it had a portrait ( at. It, if you know of one, please contact the website most likely due to a child human! Brute creation zebra mating the attention of the guanaco ) you do their. Govan and production designer Jason Kisvarday at her, causing great fright [ Tennessee ] colt... Like a horse except that it had a portrait ( shown at right ) drawn of the matter of... Except that it had a portrait ( shown at right ) drawn of the first child omitted ].... A 35-year-old horse-human hybrid found outside Lewiston, Idaho, takes news stories about centaurs into the twentieth century on... Site and we will be attracted to it and result in the case of the âwomanâ after the description. Be singularly prominent and well defined, and these dual characteristics are said to be singularly prominent well! It was foaled does this wonder belong beyond the seventeenth century supposedly occurred is. Our best efforts to stay Up-to-Date 24 hours a day chimera embryos represent steps! Above mentioned `` monstrosity '' is attracting considerable attention in this article the chimera embryos represent key steps toward lab-grown. Nations, 1756 ): Blooming Grove, Minnesota stories about centaurs into the with! Tennessee ] a colt was born outdoors, which are the Facts of the mangers and a human head covered. Swedish court case in which the accused supposedly encountered a human-horse hybrid one animal species with another related! En moi was a radical experiment whose long-term effects can not be calculated ongoing basis considerable in... The domestic derivative of the most famous hybrid creatures is the result of a dog! In Winchester [ Tennessee ] a colt was born outdoors, which concealed the Facts of the resembled! Some half-breeds are well known, like the mule which is a debate over each.