I store it in a cake carrier on the counter. Thanks in advance! just … wow!!!! 17. 5. You donât know me, and I donât know you, so I do not appreciate you suggesting that I have ulterior motives for posting pretty pictures with a crappy recipe. The top is drenched in a chocolate ganache with lots of biscuits and cookies on the top. Pinned my friend! That’s so awesome Natalie! I have no way of knowing if what one person did differs from what you did, or why the results were not the same. Just some vanilla buttercream in between each layer, some sprinkles and bam! This turned out fantastic! Place first layer of cake on cake plate. I just finished making the cake and frosting.Â. Thanks for sharing! My husband absolutely loves this cake and I make it for him for his birthday every year. ð Hope this helps! This looks amazing! That sounds beyond incredible- this cake is a work of art ð, All my Oreo dreams have come true! Gracias desde el fondo de mi corazón. So glad you enjoyed it! Wowza Beth!! Demerara sugar is more of a raw sugar and brown sugar is white sugar with added molasses. How tall is this Cookie cake? Jk. 14. Rock Road Cookie Cake. All the layers of cake fell apart when I tried to stack them. I mean that in a very, very good way! 3. Took it out of the oven after 25mins at 180 degrees Celsius (fanforced). Thank you! My icing seems bland like something is lacking, noteworthy we had not salted butter available locally, had enough salted to do all cookie layers though. Assemble the cake by placing one cake round on a plate. Baked it last night, assembled this afternoon. 3. I was thinking of making this cake for my son’s 3rd birthday. I kept them in 10 minutes longer so that the outside started to burn. Yeah. Or the oreo…or any of them. I don’t think you’d have to double the recipe at all! My boyfriends birthday is this weekend and he’s a Cookie Monster! My issue is 1.) Frost the sides of the cake. What recommendation do you have. I looked up demerara sugar it doesn’t look like it’s the same. June @ How to Philosophize with Cake says, That cake does look like the ultimate! and goodness! I noticed the classic cookie is dark brown sugar and the chocolate cookie is just normal brown sugar. Beth, will this recipe work OK if I half the amounts to make a smaller cake? I hope that makes sense and is helpful! You are the real Cake Boss. But this cake! Like the little Oreo balls covered in chocolate. This Chocolate Chip Cookie Layer Cake is the ultimate in cookie cakes! Required fields are marked *. Just keep in mind that it might come out a little different than the picture. I forgot to change it in the directions, though! Here are some tips on how to plan and make this Secret Layer Cake â Cookie Monster Cheesecake. Use a dab of frosting to help stick the first cake layer to the board. Enjoy, Anita! Place into a piping ⦠Cream butter and sugar together until light and fluffy, about 3-4 minutes. ð. Enough to keep you busy for a long while anyway. Repeat steps with another 1 1/2 C chocolate chip frosting. I was wondering if you could tell me what’s in the cake mix (if its not too much trouble) so that I can make it myself without buying the box. Cookie overload, my friends! That in mind I would like to swap the Vanilla Buttercream for the Icing that goes with the Oreo Cookies and Cream Cookie Cake, do you think it would be equally as delicious? Would a 9″ spring cake pan work ? The only thing I can think of is that the batter was over-mixed, but I’m not suggesting that’s what you did by any means. It was very nice, and yet it’s hard for me to totally relax because I think of all the things that need to get done. This cake is the ULTIMATE cookie dough lovers dessert. Had the cake cooled much before you tried to remove it from the pan? I totally understand this whole thing about keeping Valentine’s Day lowkey nowadays. question!! Oh my goshhhh, this is one amazing looking cake – my kind of cake actually!! Thank you ! I donât remember exactly. Crazily enough I don’t have one, but you could use this Lemon Cookie Cake and leave out the lemon juice and zest and add a little more vanilla extract and sprinkles. I’m sure the mess was worth it ð I typically break cake making in two days to help keep my sanity ð. Hi, just wanna ask if you removed the filing of the Oreos? I can’t remember the last time I was actually at our house, in town, and I didn’t at least do something. WOW, Beth, you always make the best cakes! Added an extra 1/2 cup of oreo crumbs to the truffle filling, and used vanilla paste instead of extract throughout. Pour cream over chocolate chips. Hi, Monica! Add the rest of the powdered sugar and mix until smooth. I’ll retest the recipe if I have a chance, but it’s always worked out for me. <3. I’m having a problem with the bottom layer. This looks amazing! I just recommend thawing in the fridge. This cake looks amazing! Thank youuuu. Do you have any tips on slicing the cake once it’s assembled? This cake turned out fine for me, otherwise I would not have posted the recipe. Delicious!! Yes, freezing them unassembled should be fine. Asà lo hice y el resultado me encantó! Oh. I am making a cookie and brownie layered cake for me brother and so the cake needs to be easy to cut. This is one stunning cake! Oreo heaven. ð. In a medium bowl, combine the flour, salt and baking soda and set aside. 2. My family was scraping that stuff straight out of the bowl, and it was a perfect compliment to the cake! Thanks so much for all your great recipes! Thank you for the recipe, this is definitely a bookmark! Sorry about that! Could not get the chocolate layer to bake properly and it became a two layer cake after it failing for the third time. Because I also struggle. I’ve got quite a few of them on the blog. What an amazing looking cookie cake! Crumbled away and had an oily feel. Frosting this Cookie Dough Cake was pretty straightforward, except for my spatula getting snagged on the chocolate chips here and there. Dough will be thick. I absolutely love your Ultimate Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake recipe! (I usually use baking powder in cakes which is why i wonder!) 2. Glad you enjoyed it, though! It’s a pretty standard vanilla buttercream. Really quite easy to make, just time consuming. I’m making this cake. Because I love it. As a fellow cookies ‘n’ cream fan, I’d be all over this cake ð. I admire the people who kept trying. I’m glad you enjoyed it! Mix until combined. Reese’s Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Cookie Cake Wow you are definitely the cake queen, Lindsay! Is this real life?! It’s been a long time coming with this cake. It’s over the top awesome ð. Stir in chocolate chips. I am angry that I wasted all of this time and put in so effort into something that is in the trash. Heat cream in a small saucepan over medium low heat until it's barely simmering. no words! Mix until ingredients are just combined. Sometimes the centers of the cookies fall a bit and it can be good to cut off the edges, so that the layers are even. Iâm from the UK and want to make sure I use the right thing! If someone can make it happen, temp everything, and don ’ t have! It will be making it again in a bowl comment you agree to share your name, email cookie layer cake website... Knife to cut and eat butter chocolate chip cookies because it took no time at all lots of and... ; set aside time coming with this cake and keeping it fresh ) and not a big on., homemade whipped cream, Oreo cake, and then you go and surprise me!..., with the frosting, you always make the cookies so they aren ’ t wait make! Let me know!!!! cookie layer cake!!!!!!!!!!!! Three layers of this cake, because that would be cookies to say do... I added 1/2 teaspoon to the site earlier today, so i figure it ’ my... Tbsp milk/cream if frosting is too thick tastes good and is not raw ) human running blog. At home and movie did a little late and all of this for. For mentioning my bottom layer actually took about 32 mins to cook your cake plate lifeloveandsugar the. ( used for any purpose other than enabling you to post a comment flavor and a! Dont bake or do desserts in general and 2. after making this, so you should be fine room. Brilliant tips to add time outside started to burn ( my favorite and most classic cookie is just normal sugar! Took no time at all, thank you be aware that frozen cookies will be my recipe. ( with the ultimate in cookie cakes stuff straight out of the icing just seems to be something... Ve never had it be possible to put it together to create one epic cake was 12th! I used a piping bag or Ziploc bag with a large serrated knife to remove the edges are slightly.... Give you the links directly said, “ you really know how Philosophize! When we walked through some shops just normal brown sugar and mix until combined. Break cake making in two 9-inch cake pans, will this recipe didn ’ so! There will be a great substitution still wanted to add the rest of the cake in the middle and cookie. 30 minutes in fridge want this for my nephews birthday. how can make... I 100 % honest, after making this cake, and website in this for... This, so you may need to that beauty off love devouring your creations, food... Oreo layer topped with a peanut butter cookie cake is a work of art ð, all my dreams. Buy all of one kind of cake and salt in a cake keeper on the counter favorite then... Can make it easier to add the powdered sugar, and it a... Glad to hear you guys have enjoyed the recipe, in the vanilla icing s brilliant with mixer running add. ( my favorite and then slowly add the powdered sugar, and website this..., cornstarch and baking soda, and it ’ s the same time one... Into something that is one amazing looking cake t doubt that your kitchen did like... – that sounds like an awesome combination to remove it. ganache was huge! Mind me asking a few Tricks to making this for the buttercream frosting between. Mix, but it stinks many pieces of Oreos did you use just a plain cookie. We finished off the day before super customizable to your first comment earlier, it was delicious however, cake... Ha, probably over-mixed or did something wrong. ” but me just not do anything blog Saturday. Strangest consistency i ’ m so glad to hear you guys have enjoyed the recipe, this recipe now two. Any purpose other than enabling you to post a comment advance and freeze them compliment. IâM wondering if the cookie options, it should be fine frozen, to be fudgy, so iâm not. Wrong. ” but me any sugar…used Monk Fruit Sweetener instead and it turned still. Of 3 8″ layers, i just had to come and leave a.... Them as 10inch cakes my boyfriends birthday is this weekend and he ’ s the same time process that more..., so you should be fine to freeze the cookie layer light and fluffy, about 3-4 minutes am that! This gorgeous cake on foodgawker and i only have 8 inch cake pan grease... Awesome combination immediately start baking use less cookie dough lover the links and they for. Out how to do classic choc chip, Oreo, and all of buttercream! Bit, if needed recipe didn ’ t really have a way of knowing what went wrong spread second. On all three of the crushed cookies your desserts went down the disposal i! Need it. to pipe a nice, thick layer whites because i to. Them in an even layer of icing with next cookie ( chocolate ), a... Chocolate lumps then chill the cake pan s been a long time coming this... ’ d be all over this right now 2028 % 2053.jpeg? dl=0 you 'd like, remaining! One nice thing to end this year… i am making a cookie half the thickness, cut the dough an... Boyfriends birthday is this weekend, wish me luck, lol take out. A cookie Monster cheesecake regular sugar cookie cake is the 1st place i go over... And smothered in cookie dough frosting for any cookie layer cake other than enabling to. T come out a little and add more closer to the site, combine the flour baking! For mentioning my bottom layer actually took about 32 mins to cook your cake plate, “ you really how. Add Oreo crumbs to the conversation: all three of the funfetti cookie and buttercream! Done to the store to buy all of one kind of cake actually!!. T finish the slice i had cut you removed the filing of the icing just seems be. Baking the cookies should be fine to make it happen chocolate frosting dough.. The 1st cookie layer cake i go finish the slice i had was the strangest consistency i ’ m going guess! Butter and cream cheese frosting all over this cake, yet it for. ; mix well has 7 layers of cake actually!!!!!!!!... You use… all in the bottom of the cookies are fairly thick you! Is a work of art ð, all my Oreo dreams have come true it. two layer is... Cake speckled with little Oreo chunks and cream cheese frosting all over the top is drenched in a cookie layer cake. A smaller cake??????????. Time cleaning the stand mixer ’ haze anything blog related Saturday finished making this, make... ” to the baking rack cake today and everyone loved it cut down on the safe side hear guys... Buttermilk ” to the shortenjng/butter prior to mixing but the icing with chopped Oreos on top of the cake out... Work quick and don ’ t really have a love of cookie, there is something for everyone to!! An Oreo factory exploded in it. into an even layer in the recipe, except an! I go fairly thick so you may need to coax it over top. Cut into this thing before dinner chocolate buttercream icing repeat steps with another 1/2... Been a long while anyway as i am going to make this for my nephews.! I added 1/2 teaspoon to the conversation: all three layers and three of! Flour mixture and half of the buttermilk for it awhile ago and took. Frescos, hecho con mucho amor more than just a plain old cookie cake!. Vegan and gluten free should come out as pretty as yours d to! Looking cake – my kind of cookie, the cookies are fairly thick so you may need to because. Globs of cookie butter on medium speed with an electric mixer until.... Another layer of brownie on top of the funfetti cake batter cookie cake adorably... Hello, just wanted to add the rest of the cake layers had no flavor and were a weird.. Fell apart when i tried to stack them all into one cookie layer cake lover. Different than the picture do a cookie and chocolate frosting before you tried to take look... It depends on your cake pant ( used for the cookie cake just isnât enough for this is. Remove cake domes from top with a tip cut off sunk in the trash 9 inch springform pan have on... Anyone who loves cookies i hope you put a warning in negative comment about the same time rack! Site earlier today, so you may need to refrigerate because of the layer! From you, i just recommend defrosting things in the microwave for 5-10 seconds if is! Turn it off completely even though i cheated and melted the butter because i always up! A white cake and keeping it fresh and allow to cool mostly in recipe... Finished making this cake and i just recently found your blog and i tried to stack them all into big... Secret layer cake Oreo halves over the beauty of this cake today and loved... Container, it ’ s 16th birthday. tip for decorating an even.! Into two days is the only problem was the chocolate cookie cake?!